Population screening for glaucoma in UK: current recommendations and future directions

Eye (Lond). 2022 Mar;36(3):504-509. doi: 10.1038/s41433-021-01687-8. Epub 2021 Aug 3.

Abstract

Effective population screening for glaucoma would enable earlier diagnosis and prevention of irreversible vision loss. The UK National Screening Committee (NSC) recently published a review that examined the viability, effectiveness and appropriateness of a population-based screening programme for primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG). In our article, we summarise the results of the review and discuss some future directions that may enable effective population screening for glaucoma in the future. Two key questions were addressed by the UK NSC review; is there a valid, accurate screening test for POAG, and does evidence exist that screening reduces morbidity from POAG compared with standard care. Six new studies were identified since the previous 2015 review. The review concluded that screening for glaucoma in adults is not recommended because there is no clear evidence for a sufficiently accurate screening test or for better outcomes with screening compared to current care. The next UK NSC review is due to be conducted in 2023. One challenge for POAG screening is that the relatively low disease prevalence results in too many false-positive referrals, even with an accurate test. In the future, targeted screening of a population subset with a higher prevalence of glaucoma may be effective. Recent developments in POAG polygenic risk prediction and deep learning image analysis offer potential avenues to identifying glaucoma-enriched sub-populations. Until such time, opportunistic case finding through General Ophthalmic Services remains the primary route for identification of glaucoma in the UK and greater public awareness of the service would be of benefit.

摘要

对青光眼进行有效的筛查有助于疾病的早期诊断和预防不可逆转的视力丧失。英国国家筛查委员会 (NSC) 最近发表了一篇综述, 研究了以人群为基础的原发性开角型青光眼 (POAG) 筛查方案的可行性、有效性和适宜性。在我们的文章中, 我们总结了这篇综述的结果, 并讨论了一些未来可能使青光眼进行有效的 (人群筛查实现的方向。英国国家安全委员会审查提出了两个关键问题: 第一, 是否有一个有效并准确的POAG筛查检测; 第二, 是否有证据表明, 筛查与标准治疗方案相比降低了POAG的发病率。自2015年这篇综述发表以来, 又有6项新的研究发表。该综述的结论是, 不建议对成人进行青光眼筛查, 因为没有明确的证据表明筛查检测足够准确, 也没有证据表明筛查比目前的治疗效果更好。英国国家安全委员会的下一次评估将于2023年进行。

POAG筛查面临的一个挑战是, 即使进行了准确的检测, 相对较低的发病率也能导致大量的假阳性转诊。在未来, 对青光眼高发人群进行针对性筛查可能是有效的。POAG多基因风险预测和深度学习图像分析的最新进展给识别丰富的青光眼分类提供了潜在的途径。在此之前, 通过普通眼科检查偶然发现的病例仍然是英国青光眼的主要发现途径, 提高公众对该项检查的认识将是有益的。

Publication types

  • Review

MeSH terms

  • Adult
  • Early Diagnosis
  • Glaucoma* / diagnosis
  • Glaucoma* / epidemiology
  • Glaucoma, Open-Angle* / diagnosis
  • Glaucoma, Open-Angle* / epidemiology
  • Humans
  • Mass Screening / methods
  • Prevalence
  • United Kingdom / epidemiology