Experimental characterization of Lamb waves in plate-like structures overcomes the intrinsic limits of a priori semianalytical finite element simulations, where material inaccuracies and nonidealities cannot be easily considered. Unfortunately, the experimental extraction of guided wave dispersion curves, and especially their polar representation along different directions of propagation at a given frequency, is not trivial. In nonisotropic materials, such analysis is a key aspect for a reliable and robust characterization of the behavior of waves. In this work, by exploiting scanning laser Doppler vibrometer measurements with narrowband excitation, two different signal processing methods for the extraction of the wavenumber polar representation at the excitation frequency are investigated and characterized. The first method is based on a distance regularized level set (DRLSE) algorithm, widely used in image processing and computer vision but, to the best of the author's knowledge, never used in the Lamb waves' field. The second method is based on the 2-D sparse wavenumber analysis which exploits the wavefield sparse representation in the wavenumber domain. With a precise and reliable extraction of the wavenumber characteristic in the k -space, the polar representations at the excitation frequency of phase and group velocities can be estimated. The former, by exploiting the well-known wavenumber-frequency relation, the latter, instead, by computing numerical derivative among wavenumbers at multiple frequencies. The methodology has been validated on three different composite plates with different degrees of nonisotropy properties. The results show the effectiveness of the two methods, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of both.