Contact toxicity assessments of six reduced risk insecticides were carried out to compare their selectivity and sensitivity toward the minute pirate bug Orius strigicollis and its prey Thrips hawaiiensis. Additionally, and their potential exposure risk were evaluated for O. strigicollis. The LR50 value of acetamiprid, emamectin benzoate, cyetpyrafen, and indoxacarb to T. hawaiiensis were 0.126, 2.093, 7.486, and 2.264 g a.i. ha-1, respectively, far less than the maximum field recommended rate (MFRR) for each. These four insecticides showed higher selectivity for predator and prey with selectivity ratio values of 37.3, 14.8, 22.1, and 119.3, respectively. However, the LR50 value of acetamiprid and emamectin benzoate were lower than MFRR, and unacceptable (approximately unacceptable for emamectin benzoate) risk to O. strigicollis in in-field, and the opposite results were shown in cyetpyrafen and indoxacarb. Although T. hawaiiensis was more sensitive to abamectin than O. strigicollis, the insecticide had poor selectivity for both test insects. The LR50 value of spirotetramat was more than 3 fold MFRR for T. hawaiiensis and O. strigicollis, showing extremely low contact toxicity and selectivity. In general, acetamiprid, emamectin benzoate, cyetpyrafen, and indoxacarb showed high bioactivity against T. hawaiiensis, but only cyetpyrafen and indoxacarb could be well compatible with O. strigicollis, the combination of two insecticides with O. strigicollis indicated a potential strategy for the efficient and safe control of T. hawaiiensis.
Keywords: Hawaiian flower thrips; Minute pirate bug; Reduced-risk insecticide; Risk assessment; Selectivity; Toxicity.
Copyright © 2021 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.