Endogenous Staphylococcus aureus sortase A (SrtA) covalently incorporates cell wall anchored proteins equipped with a SrtA recognition motif (LPXTG) via a lipid II-dependent pathway into the staphylococcal peptidoglycan layer. Previously, we found that the endogenous S. aureus SrtA is able to recognize and process a variety of exogenously added synthetic SrtA substrates, including K(FITC)LPMTG-amide and K(FITC)-K-vancomycin-LPMTG-amide. These synthetic substrates are covalently incorporated into the bacterial peptidoglycan (PG) of S. aureus with varying efficiencies. In this study, we examined if native and synthetic substrates are processed by SrtA via the same pathway. Therefore, the effect of the lipid II inhibiting antibiotic bacitracin on the incorporation of native and synthetic SrtA substrates was assessed. Treatment of S. aureus with bacitracin resulted in a decreased incorporation of protein A in the bacterial cell wall, whereas incorporation of exogenous synthetic substrates was increased. These results suggest that natural and exogenous synthetic substrates are processed by S. aureus via different pathways.