Beating heart (BH) and thigh muscle (TM) are two pre-clinical models aimed at studying the lesion sizes created by radiofrequency (RF) catheters in cardiac ablation. Previous experimental results have shown that thermal lesions created in the TM are slightly bigger than in the BH. Our objective was to use in-silico modeling to elucidate some of the causes of this difference. In-silico RF ablation models were created using the Arrhenius function to estimate lesion size under different energy settings (25 W/20 s, 50 W/6 s and 90 W/4 s) and parallel, 45° and perpendicular catheter positions. The models consisted of homogeneous tissue: myocardium in the BH model and striated muscle in the TM model. The computer results showed that the lesion sizes were generally bigger in the TM model and the differences depended on the energy setting, with hardly any differences at 90 W/4 s but with differences of 1 mm in depth and 1.5 m in width at 25 W/20 s. The higher electrical conductivity of striated muscle (0.446 S/m) than that of the myocardium (0.281 S/m) is possibly one of the causes of the higher percentage of RF energy delivered to the tissue in the TM model, with differences between models of 2-5% at 90 W/4 s, ~9% at 50 W/6 s and ~10% at 25 W/20 s. Proximity to the air-blood interface (just 2 cm from the tissue surface) artificially created in the TM model to emulate the cardiac cavity had little effect on lesion size. In conclusion, the TM-based experimental model creates fairly similar-sized lesions to the BH model, especially in high-power short-duration ablations (50 W/6 s and 90 W/4 s). Our computer results suggest that the higher electrical conductivity of striated muscle could be one of the causes of the slightly larger lesions in the TM model.
Keywords: beating heart; cardiac ablation; computer modeling; radiofrequency ablation; thigh muscle.