Advances in Delivery of Selective Internal Radiation Therapy (SIRT): Economic and Logistical Effects of Same-Stay Work-Up and Procedure in the Treatment of Unresectable Liver Tumors in England

Abstract

Introduction: Selective internal radiation therapy (SIRT) is a targeted method of treatment for unresectable liver tumors in which radiation therapy is directly delivered to the tumor(s) via the hepatic vasculature. Successful outcomes with SIRT are dependent on the specific vasculature of the liver and tumor, and the patient therefore needs to attend a "work-up" to map the hepatic vasculature prior to the SIRT procedure. Recent advances in SIRT delivery have enabled same-day or same-stay work-up and procedure, requiring only one hospital visit rather than two. We aimed to evaluate the economic, travel time, and transport-related environmental impact of a new brachytherapy device delivery program, the order-map-treat (OMT) program, in patients with unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in England.

Methods: A healthcare resource group (HRG)-based analysis of costs from a national payer (Department of Health and Social Care, DHSC) perspective was conducted assuming that, with OMT, patients would have to attend hospital only once for both the SIRT work-up and procedure versus twice without OMT. Patient travel time and CO₂ emissions were then estimated by identifying the SIRT center closest to the centroid of each clinical commissioning group (CCG) and calculating straight-line distances with a "detour index" to capture the effect of indirect routes via road or rail.

Results: It was estimated that 856 patients per annum would be eligible for SIRT treatment for unresectable HCC in England. OMT would be anticipated to save GBP 2842 per patient versus performing SIRT without OMT. Furthermore, across all patients with HCC eligible for SIRT in England, OMT would avoid 74,500 km of travel, 2299 h of travel time, and 13.9 metric tons of patient transport-related CO₂ emissions annually.

Conclusion: OMT reduces the number of hospital visits required for SIRT by 50%, resulting in financial savings from the DHSC perspective, time savings from the patient perspective, and reduced CO₂ emissions arising from patient transport.

Keywords: Brachytherapy; Costs and cost analysis; Organization and administration; Yttrium.