Critically-timed sleep+light interventions differentially improve mood in pregnancy vs. postpartum depression by shifting melatonin rhythms

Abstract

Background: Testing the hypothesis that combined wake + light therapy improves mood in pregnant vs. postpartum depressed participants (DP) by differentially altering melatonin and sleep timing.

Methods: Initially 89 women, 37 pregnant (21 normal controls-NC; 16 DP) and 52 postpartum (27 NCs; 25 DP), were randomized to a parallel trial of a phase-delay intervention (PDI): 1-night of early-night wake therapy (sleep 3-7 am) + 6-weeks of evening bright white light (Litebook Advantage) for 60 min starting 90 min before bedtime, vs. a Phase-advance intervention (PAI): 1-night of late-night wake therapy (sleep 9 pm-1 am) + 6-weeks of morning bright white light for 60 min within 30 min of wake time. Blinded clinicians assessed mood weekly by structured interview, and participants completed subjective ratings, a Morningness-Eveningness questionnaire, actigraphy, and collected 2 overnight urine samples for 6-sulphatoxy melatonin (6-SMT).

Results: In pregnant DP, mood improved more after the PDI vs. PAI (p = .016), whereas in postpartum DP, mood improved more after the PAI vs. PDI (p = .019). After wake therapy, 2 weeks of light treatment was as efficacious as 6 weeks (p > .05). In postpartum DP, PAI phase-advanced 6-SMT offset and acrophase (p < .05), which correlated positively with mood improvement magnitude (p = .003).

Limitations: Small N.

Conclusions: Mood improved more after 2 weeks of the PDI in pregnant DP, but more after 2 weeks of PAI in postpartum DP in which improvement magnitude correlated with 6-SMT phase-advance. Thus, critically-timed Sleep + Light Interventions provide safe, efficacious, rapid-acting, well-tolerated, at-home, non-pharmaceutical treatments for peripartum DP.

Keywords: Chronotherapy; Light treatment; Melatonin; Peripartum depression; Sleep; Wake therapy.