Canonical sexual reproduction among basidiomycete fungi involves the fusion of two haploid individuals of different sexes, resulting in a heterokaryotic mycelial body made up of genetically different nuclei 1 . Using population genomics data, we discovered mushrooms of the deadly invasive Amanita phalloides are also homokaryotic, evidence of sexual reproduction by single individuals. In California, genotypes of homokaryotic mushrooms are also found in heterokaryotic mushrooms, implying nuclei of homokaryotic mycelia also promote outcrossing. We discovered death cap mating is controlled by a single mating-type locus ( A. phalloides is bipolar), but the development of homokaryotic mushrooms appears to bypass mating-type gene control. Ultimately, sporulation is enabled by nuclei able to reproduce alone as well as with others, and nuclei competent for both unisexuality and bisexuality have persisted in invaded habitats for at least 17 but potentially as long as 30 years. The diverse reproductive strategies of invasive death caps are likely facilitating its rapid spread, revealing a profound similarity between plant, animal and fungal invasions 2,3 .