Investigation of Calcium and Magnesium Removal by Donnan Dialysis According to the Doehlert Design for Softening Different Water Types

Membranes (Basel). 2023 Feb 7;13(2):203. doi: 10.3390/membranes13020203.

Abstract

In this study, calcium and magnesium were removed from Tunisian dam, lake, and tap water using Donnan Dialysis (DD) according to the Doehlert design. Three cation-exchange membranes (CMV, CMX, and CMS) were used in a preliminary investigation to establish the upper and lower bounds of each parameter and to more precisely pinpoint the optimal value. The concentration of compensating sodium ions [Na+] in the receiver compartment, the concentration of calcium [Ca2+] and magnesium [Mg2+] in the feed compartment, and the membrane nature were the experimental parameters. The findings indicate that the CMV membrane offers the highest elimination rate of calcium and magnesium. The Full Factorial Design makes it possible to determine how the experimental factors affect the removal of calcium and magnesium by DD. All parameters used had a favorable impact on the response; however, the calcium and magnesium concentration were the most significant ones. The Doehlert design's Response Surface Methodology (RSM) was used to determine the optimum conditions ([Mg2+] = 90 mg·L-1, [Ca2+] = 88 mg·L-1, [Na+] = 0.68 mol·L-1) allowing a 90.6% hardness removal rate with the CMV membrane. Finally, we used Donnan Dialysis to remove calcium and magnesium from the three different types of natural water: Dam, Lake, and Tap water. The results indicate that, when compared to lake water and tap water, the removal of calcium and magnesium from dam water is the best. This can be linked to the water matrix's complexity. Therefore, using Donnan Dialysis to decrease natural waters hardness was revealed to be suitable.

Keywords: Donnan Dialysis; hardness; response surface methodology; water softening.

Grants and funding

This research received no external funding.