If I Could Do It, So Can They: Among the Rich, Those With Humbler Origins are Less Sensitive to the Difficulties of the Poor

Hyunjin J Koo; Paul K Piff; Azim F Shariff

doi:10.1177/19485506221098921

If I Could Do It, So Can They: Among the Rich, Those With Humbler Origins are Less Sensitive to the Difficulties of the Poor

Soc Psychol Personal Sci. 2023 Apr;14(3):333-341. doi: 10.1177/19485506221098921. Epub 2022 Jun 27.

Authors

Hyunjin J Koo¹, Paul K Piff¹, Azim F Shariff²

Affiliations

¹ University of California, Irvine, USA.
² The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.

Abstract

Americans venerate rags-to-riches stories. Here we show that people view those who became rich more positively than those born rich and expect the Became Rich to be more sympathetic toward social welfare (Studies 1a and b). However, we also find that these intuitions are misguided. Surveys of wealthy individuals (Studies 2a and b) reveal that, compared with the Born Rich, the Became Rich perceive improving one's socioeconomic conditions as less difficult, which, in turn, predicts less empathy for the poor, less perceived sacrifices by the poor, more internal attributions for poverty, and less support for redistribution. Corroborating this, imagining having experienced upward mobility (vs. beginning and staying at the top) causes people to view such mobility as less difficult, reducing empathy and support for those failing to move up (Study 3). These findings suggest that becoming rich may shift views about the poor in ways that run counter to common intuitions and cultural assumptions.

Keywords: attitudes toward the poor; redistribution; rich; social mobility; socioeconomic status.