Apoptotic inhibition and immune evasion have particular importance to efficient viral infection, while a dilemma often faced by viruses is that inhibiting apoptosis can up-regulate antiviral immune signaling. Herein, we uncovered that in addition to inhibiting caspase-8/extrinsic apoptosis, human cytomegalovirus (HCMV)-encoded UL36 suppresses interferon regulatory factor 3 (IRF3)-dependent immune signaling by directly targeting IRF3 to abrogate IRF3 interaction with stimulator of interferon genes or TANK-binding kinase 1 and inhibit IRF3 phosphorylation/activation. Although UL36-mediated caspase-8/extrinsic apoptosis inhibition enhances immune signaling, the immunosuppressing activity of UL36 counterbalances this immunoenhancing "side effect" undesirable for virus. Furthermore, we used mutational analyses to show that only the wild-type, but not the UL36 mutant losing either inhibitory activity, is sufficient to support effective HCMV replication in cells, showing the functional importance of the dual inhibition by UL36 for the HCMV life cycle. Together, our findings demonstrate a sophisticated mechanism by which HCMV tightly controls innate immune signaling and extrinsic apoptosis for efficient infection.