Using "Real-World Data" to Study Cleft Lip/Palate Care: An Exploration of Speech Outcomes from a Multi-Center US Learning Health Network

Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2023 Oct 16:10556656231207469. doi: 10.1177/10556656231207469. Online ahead of print.

Abstract

Objective: To assess the ability of a cleft-specific multi-site learning health network registry to describe variations in cleft outcomes by cleft phenotypes, ages, and treatment centers. Observed variations were assessed for coherence with prior study findings.

Design: Cross-sectional analysis of prospectively collected data from 2019-2022.

Setting: Six cleft treatment centers collected data systematically during routine clinic appointments according to a standardized protocol.

Participants: 714 English-speaking children and adolescents with non-syndromic cleft lip/palate.

Intervention: Routine multidisciplinary care and systematic outcomes measurement by cleft teams.

Outcome measures: Speech outcomes included articulatory accuracy measured by Percent Consonants Correct (PCC), velopharyngeal function measured by Velopharyngeal Competence (VPC) Rating Scale (VPC-R), intelligibility measured by caregiver-reported Intelligibility in Context Scale (ICS), and two CLEFT-Q™ surveys, in which patients rate their own speech function and level of speech distress.

Results: 12year-olds exhibited high median PCC scores (91-100%), high frequency of velopharyngeal competency (62.50-100%), and high median Speech Function (80-91) relative to younger peers parsed by phenotype. Patients with bilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate reported low PCC scores (51-91%) relative to peers at some ages and low frequency of velopharyngeal competency (26.67%) at 5 years. ICS scores ranged from 3.93-5.0 for all ages and phenotypes. Speech Function and Speech Distress were similar across phenotypes.

Conclusions: This exploration of speech outcomes demonstrates the current ability of the cleft-specific registry to support cleft research efforts as a source of "real-world" data. Further work is focused on developing robust methodology for hypothesis-driven research and causal inference.

Keywords: articulation; cleft lip; cleft lip and palate; cleft palate; nasality; nonsyndromic clefting; outcomes; pediatrics; registry; resonance; speech assessment; speech development; speech disorders; velopharyngeal dysfunction; velopharyngeal function.