Background: Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) is a severe life-threatening metabolic disorder. Patients' poor outcomes could be prevented by early diagnosis and regular monitoring, which mainly depend on the analysis of branched amino acids (BCAAs) in plasma. The study aimed to test whether the analysis of BCAAs by ultra-performance liquid chromatography (UPLC) is an alternative to an analysis by ion-exchange chromatography (IEC) for the diagnosis and monitoring of MSUD.
Methods: The two methods analyzed fifty plasma samples obtained from treated and untreated patients with MSUD. Data were analyzed using Passing-Bablok and Bland-Altman methods.
Results: The slope of the regression lines was equal or close to one for the three BCAAs, indicating no significant proportional differences between the two methods. A slight positive or negative bias was found for leucine and alloisoleucine, respectively. However, for each amino acid, one or two measurement pairs were out of statistical interval of agreement. Despite small analytical differences, the two methods could be considered in clinical agreement since the differences have no impact on the diagnosis and management of patients.
Conclusions: UPLC and IEC methods are in clinical agreement for plasma BCAAs analysis. The UPLC method could be used simultaneously or interchangeably with the IEC method for diagnosing and monitoring MSUD patients. However, for reasons of practicability, the alternative method should only be used when the usual method cannot be carried out.