A majority of short peptide (≤7 amino acids) hydrogels are primarily assembled via cross β-structure formation. In contrast to the natural trend, herein, we report the formation of supramolecular hydrogel from the ultrashort hybrid folded peptide composed of canonical α-amino acid and noncanonical γ-amino acid, Fmoc-γPhe-Phe-OH. The designed hybrid peptide hydrogel is composed of entangled fibers, has viscoelastic properties, exhibits proteolytic stability, and exhibits cytocompatibility with L929 fibroblast cells. Mutating the peptide sequence by altering the position of γPhe from the N-termini to C-termini transforms the self-assembly into crystalline aggregates. Combining FTIR, 2D NMR, and DFT calculations revealed that the hydrogel-forming peptide adopts a C9 H-bonded conformation, resembling the well-known γ-turn. However, the isomeric hybrid peptide adopts an extended structure. The present study highlights the importance of secondary structure in the higher order assembly of minimalist hybrid peptides and broadens the range of secondary structures to design short peptide-based hydrogels.