Task-relevant visual feedback uncertainty attenuates visuomotor adaptation

J Neurophysiol. 2024 Sep 1;132(3):879-889. doi: 10.1152/jn.00180.2024. Epub 2024 Aug 7.

Abstract

Motor adaptation is attenuated when sensory feedback about the movement is uncertain. Although this was initially shown for small visual errors, attenuation seems not to hold when visual errors are larger and the contributions of implicit adaptation are isolated with the error-clamp method, which makes visual feedback task-irrelevant. Here we ask whether adaptation to a similarly large perturbation is attenuated when task-relevant visual feedback is uncertain. In a first experiment, we tested participants on a 30° movement-contingent visuomotor rotation under both low (cursor) and high (cloud of moving dots) visual feedback uncertainty. In line with optimal integration, we found that the early increase in adaptation and final extent of adaptation were reduced with high feedback uncertainty. In a second experiment, we included several blocks of no-feedback trials during the perturbation block to quantify the contribution of implicit adaptation. Results showed that implicit adaptation was smaller with high compared to low feedback uncertainty throughout the perturbation block. The estimated contribution of explicit adaptation was overall small, particularly for high feedback uncertainty. Our results demonstrate an influence of task-relevant visual feedback, and the resulting target errors, on implicit adaptation. We show that our motor system is sensitive to the feedback it receives even for larger error sizes and accordingly adjusts its learning properties when our ability to achieve the task goal is affected.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Motor adaptation is linked to the estimation of our actions. Whereas uncertainty of task-irrelevant visual feedback appears not to influence implicit adaptation for errors beyond a certain size, here we tested whether this is still the case for task-relevant feedback. We show that implicit adaptation is attenuated when task-relevant visual feedback is uncertain, suggesting a dependency on the assessment of not just sensory prediction errors but also target errors.

Keywords: motor adaptation; task-relevant error; visual feedback uncertainty.

MeSH terms

  • Adaptation, Physiological* / physiology
  • Adult
  • Feedback, Sensory* / physiology
  • Female
  • Humans
  • Male
  • Psychomotor Performance* / physiology
  • Uncertainty
  • Visual Perception* / physiology
  • Young Adult