Poly-(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors (PARPi) block NAD+-binding pocket of PARP1, inhibiting PAR synthesis. However, they differ in their ability to retain PARP1 on damaged DNA to induce synthetic lethality in homologous recombination-deficient (HRD) cancer. Allosteric enzymatic activation requires destabilization of the helical domain (HD) of PARP1 and is indispensable for activation and chromatin retention induced by distinct PARPi. Here we report that the effect of the clinical PARPi talazoparib is robustly impacted by a common human polymorphism within the HD. PARP1V762 greatly enhanced talazoparib-driven allosteric retention on chromatin, prolonged XRCC1 recruitment, and enhanced cell killing. Talazoparib switches from Type-II PARPi behavior in PARP1A762 to allosteric, pro-retention Type-I behavior for PARP1V762. Thus, both PARPi efficacy and dose-limiting tolerability depends on PARP1 allele, motivating variant-guided cancer therapies.