A defining feature of substance use disorder is that repeated drug use does not always lead to addiction, motivating the search for biomarkers of vulnerability1. Reduced striatal dopamine D2/3 receptor availability is a robust PET correlate of problematic stimulant use2-5, but the signal may reflect high endogenous dopamine level, and it conflates presynaptic D2 autoreceptors on dopamine axons with postsynaptic D2/3 heteroreceptors on striatal projection neurons. We dissociated these contributions using cell type-specific Drd2 haploinsufficiency in dopamine neurons (autoD2KD), D2-expressing medium spiny neurons (MSN-D2KD), or both. Autoreceptor haploinsufficiency (autoD2KD) weakened presynaptic control of dopamine release, enhanced phasic gain, and prolonged cocaine-evoked dopamine elevations. This was accompanied by a hyper-exploratory trait and altered cocaine adaptation. Specifically, autoD2KD mice showed greater cocaine-seeking behavior, despite intact responses to sucrose reward and punishment. Although all genotypes showed graded reductions in striatal D2/3 binding, D1-like compensations diverged, resulting in different D1:D2/3 ratio in the striatum. The clinical implication is that striatal D1 density and D1:D2/3 balance may emerge as critical biomarkers for distinguishing cell-type-specific D2 reductions relevant to addiction vulnerability.