Objectives: To compare cognitive load during virtual reality (VR) simulation and cadaveric dissection (CD) mastoidectomy training in novice learners. To determine whether training order influences cognitive load, characterize cognitive load progression during the procedure, and assess whether VR training improves subsequent cadaveric performance.
Methods: In this randomized crossover study, 24 core surgical trainees with no prior mastoidectomy experience performed a cortical mastoidectomy in both VR and CD settings. Participants were randomized to either VR-first or CD-first training sequences. Cognitive load was measured using a bespoke auditory reaction-time device at baseline and 10, 30, and 50 min. Relative reaction time (RRT) served as an objective index of cognitive load. Cadaveric performance was assessed using the Modified Welling Scale by two blinded otologists.
Results: Cognitive load was significantly lower during VR than CD, with mean RRT rising 26% from baseline in VR versus 60% in CD (p < 0.001). Training order did not affect cognitive load in either modality, and RRT increased progressively throughout mastoidectomy in both VR and CD. Participants who began with VR achieved significantly higher cadaveric performance scores than those who began with CD (mean 9.50 vs. 4.96; p < 0.001), and inter-rater reliability for performance scoring was high.
Conclusion: VR mastoidectomy reduces cognitive load and enhances subsequent cadaveric performance in novice trainees, supporting its role as a cognitively optimized precadaver training modality that complements, rather than replaces, cadaveric dissection. These findings suggest VR enhances early learning efficiency and resource utilization in novice otolaryngology training.
Level of evidence: N/A.
Keywords: cadaveric dissection; cognitive load; mastoidectomy; reaction time; surgical education; virtual reality simulation.
© 2026 The American Laryngological, Rhinological and Otological Society, Inc.