Validity of self-assessment of sexual maturation in adolescent male patients with cystic fibrosis

Abstract

Purpose: Self-assessment of sexual maturity by healthy male adolescents has been found to correlate closely with physician ratings. Data are lacking, however, in adolescents with cystic fibrosis (CF), where an altered body image may affect self-assessment. Delayed sexual maturation occurs in many patients with CF, particularly those with severe disease. We hypothesized that self-assessment of sexual maturation by adolescents with CF would agree with physician ratings.

Methods: Using Tanner's standard photographs for pubic hair (PH) and genital (G) development, we compared self-assessment of sexual maturation to physician rating in 34 adolescent male patients with CF and 27 healthy male controls (C).

Results: The two groups did not differ in age. All subjects were initially examined and Tanner-staged by a physician (SRB), and instructed in self-assessment using the Tanner photographs; they then performed a self-assessment. Scores by physician and subjects were assessed for inter-observer agreement by Kappa analysis. For the CF group, 29 of 34 PH assessments and 21 of 34 G assessments demonstrated exact inter-observer agreement between physician and subject ratings. The Kappa coefficient, kappa, (weighted for the degree of closeness between two observers) was 0.946 for PH and 0.840 for G and the C group, kappa was 0.905 for PH and 0.737 for G. Repeat analysis combining stages 3 and 4 PH and G development yielded higher inter-observer agreement in the CF group (33 of 34 PH assessments and 26 of 34 G assessments) and in the C group (24 of 27 PH assessments and 18 of 27 G assessments).

Conclusions: Self-assessment is a valid method to assess sexual maturity in clinical evaluation and as a research tool in the study of patients with CF.