Study design: This study was designed to determine the current experience in the use of chymopapain injection in the treatment of herniated intervertebral discs by analyzing reports appearing between 1985 and 1993. Forty-five clinical studies included 7,335 patients treated worldwide, some including comparisons to open laminectomy/discectomy and others to percutaneous discectomy.
Objectives: Because controversy persists after 30 years of clinical use of chymopapain, the results of current experience should establish the efficacy for those who want to consider chemonucleolysis as a treatment for a herniated nucleus pulposus.
Summary of background data: There is the suggestion that use of other than conservative treatment is made only to achieve a better result in the short term. The selection of type of treatment will depend on contraindications, with failures of chemonucleolysis found largely in those having spinal stenosis or sequestrated discs. Worker compensation patients respond less successfully than those with better motivation.
Methods: The 45 studies were analyzed for determination of successful outcome and divided into 16 with more than 100 patients, 13 with less than 100 patients and 16 with comparison to other treatments.
Results: Individual success rates exceeded 60% whereas cohort total averaged 76%. In studies comparing chemonucleolysis with open discectomy, success rate averaged 76.2% as compared with 88% for open surgery. In two other studies, percutaneous discectomy was less successful than chemonucleolysis. Where included, duration of hospitalization showed less time and thus less costs for chemonucleolysis. Return to work complications showed time off slightly less for chemonucleolysis than for laminectomy.
Conclusions: Chemonucleolysis, though somewhat less effective than open discectomy, can be successfully and safely used in about four of five carefully selected patients without the trauma, risks, and subsequent fibrosis associated with lumbar disc surgery.