Background: The response to contracture tests may depend upon the relative proportion of muscle fiber types within the muscle specimen. To determine whether a difference in fiber-type caffeine sensitivities exists between malignant hyperthermia susceptible (MHS) and malignant hyperthermia-nonsusceptible (MHN) skeletal muscle, we compared the fiber-type caffeine sensitivities in chemically skinned muscle fibers dissected from vastus lateralis muscle from 15 MHS and 16 MHN patients.
Methods: Muscle fiber type was determined in each fiber by the difference in strontium-induced tension measurements and in 36 fibers, after contracture testing, by ATPase enzyme histochemistry. Caffeine sensitivity was defined as the threshold concentration inducing more than 10% of the maximal tension obtained with a calcium 1.6 x 10(-2) mM solution.
Results: Significant difference in the mean (+/- SD) caffeine sensitivity was found between type I MHS fibers (2.63 +/- 0.85 mM) versus type II MHS fibers (3.47 +/- 1.2 mM) and between type I MHN fibers (5.89 +/- 1.8 mM) versus type II MHN fibers (10.46 +/- 2.6 mM). The mean (+/- SD) caffeine sensitivities for a given muscle fiber type (I or II) were different between groups of MHS and MHN patients. Both type I and II MHS fibers had significantly lower caffeine sensitivities, and this increase in caffeine sensitivity was significantly smaller in type I than in type II fiber.
Conclusions: The current study indicates that a truly MHS patient cannot have a false-negative result solely related to abnormal type II fibers contained in a given muscle strip. Although the occurrence of a very high proportion of type I fibers in MHN human muscle could result in a false-positive contracture outcome, such an occurrence is expected to be rare.