Five types of limited contact dynamic compression plates (LC-DCPs) of pure titanium with different surface treatments and an electropolished stainless steel LC-DCP were tested. The surface roughness parameters and chemical surface conditions were determined and checked for probable surface contamination. After an implantation period of 3 months on long bones of sheep, the soft tissue adjacent to the plates was evaluated histomorphometrically. The difference in roughness parameters was statistically significant for most surface conditions. A correlation was found between the surface roughness of the implants and the thickness of the adjacent soft tissue layer. The thinnest soft tissue reaction layer with a good adhesion to the implant surface was observed for the titanium anodized plates with coarse surface. Smooth implants, in particular the electropolished stainless steel plates, induced statistically significant thicker soft tissue layers. Profilometer roughness measurements combined with scanning electron microscopy techniques were useful methods to characterize the surface morphology.