Enhancement in the region of the jugular foramen on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is highly sensitive to the presence of a skull base neoplasm. Unfortunately, this imaging method lacks the specificity to be the sole criterion in the diagnosis of a lesion of the jugular foramen. Although well described in the radiological literature, the phenomenon of gadolinium enhancement of the relatively static blood in the jugular system continues to be erroneously diagnosed as glomus jugulare tumor. Instances of this phenomenon present in patients referred to our practice for surgical opinions before radiation therapy and/or definitive resection will be presented. The purpose of this communication is to bring this potential treatment pitfall to the attention of the neurotology community. Treatment planning for lesions of the lateral skull base cannot singularly be based on MRI findings but requires a healthy skepticism satisfied only by more complete evaluation.