A 24-hour urine collection for 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (HIAA) is commonly performed to evaluate patients with suspected carcinoid syndrome. However, carcinoids are rare, and elevated results are common even when using an analytically specific method. To characterize this problem, the incidence of elevated results was examined in a population of 947 patient specimens received in a clinical reference laboratory setting. Using a reference limit of 15 mg/d identified 7.9 percent of the results as elevated, with 3 percent > 100 mg/d, and about 1 percent > 350 mg/d. Males showed 14 percent > 15 mg/d compared to 5.2 percent for females. Characterization of incomplete and excess 24-hr urine collections is facilitated by use of a creatinine ratio, with a reference limit of 14 mg/g creatinine equivalent to 15 mg/d. Given the frequency of elevated results, HIAA should be used to support the diagnoses of carcinoid only when consistent with other objective findings.