Gastric tonometer PCO2 measurement may help identify gut ischemia in critically ill patients but is frequently associated with large measurement errors. We tested the hypothesis that small bowel tonometer PCO2 measurement yields more accurate information. In 10 anesthetized, mechanically ventilated pigs subject to progressive hemorrhage, we measured gut oxygen delivery and consumption. We also measured tonometer PCO2 minus arterial PCO2 (DeltaPCO2) and calculated the corresponding intracellular pH from tonometers placed in the stomach and jejunum. We found that the correlation coefficient (r2) for biphasic gut oxygen delivery-DeltaPCO2 relationships was 0.29 +/- 0.52 for the gastric tonometer vs. 0.76 +/- 0.25 for the small bowel tonometer (P < 0.05). In addition, the critical gastric tonometer DeltaPCO2 was excessively high and variable (62.9 +/- 39.6) compared with the critical small bowel tonometer DeltaPCO2 (17.0 +/- 15.0, P < 0.01). Small bowel tonometer PCO2 was closely correlated with superior mesenteric vein PCO2 (r2 = 0.81, P < 0.001), whereas gastric tonometer PCO2 was not (r2 = -0.13, P = not significant). We conclude that measurement of gastric tonometer PCO2 yields excessively noisy and inaccurate data on the onset of gut anaerobic metabolism in hemorrhagic shock. Small bowel tonometer PCO2 is less noisy and, as a result, is superior in detecting gut hypoperfusion and the onset of anaerobic metabolism.