alpha-Dicarbonyls, generated by sugar degradation, catalyze the formation of the so-called Strecker aldehydes from alpha-amino acids. To check the effectiveness of Amadori compounds (suggested as important intermediates in alpha-dicarbonyl formation from carbohydrates) in Strecker aldehyde formation, the amounts of phenylacetaldehyde (PA) formed from either an aqueous solution of L-phenylalanine/glucose or the corresponding Amadori compound N-(1-deoxy-D-fructosyl-1-yl)-L-phenylalanine (ARP-Phe) were compared. The results revealed the ARP-Phe as a much more effective precursor in PA generation. On the contrary, a binary mixture of glucose/phenylalanine yielded preferentially phenylacetic acid, in particular, when reacted in the presence of oxygen and copper ions. Further model experiments gave evidence that a transition-metal-catalyzed oxidation of the ARP-Phe by air oxygen into the 2-hexosulose-(phenylalanine) imine is the key step responsible for the favored formation of phenylacetaldehyde from the Amadori compound. This mechanism might explain differences in the ratios of Strecker aldehydes and the corresponding acids depending on the structures of carbohydrate degradation products involved.