This retrospective review study, carried out in a private IVF clinic, compared pregnancy and implantation rates with day 3 versus day 5 embryo transfers in a selected group of patients. Participants were patients who failed to achieve pregnancy in at least one previous attempt with embryo transfer on days 2 or 3, and had more than five oocytes fertilized. A total of 296 patients who had undergone day 3 (group A) transfers were compared with 154 who had undergone day 5 transfers (group B). Interventions were intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), day 3 and day 5 embryo transfer. Outcome measures were pregnancy, implantation, multiple gestation and blastocyst formation rates. Overall, 86.4% of embryos were at the six- to eight-cell stage at 72 h and 30% developed to blastocyst by day 5. The mean number of embryos transferred was 4.0 on day 3 and 3.0 on day 5. Pregnancy and implantation rates were 34.8 and 11.5% in group A, versus 45.3 and 18.5% in group B. Multiple gestation rate was 47.1% in group A and 28.5% in group B. Prolonging embryo culture in vitro to day 5 improved embryo selection and implantation rates. A significant decrease in high order gestations was achieved by reducing the number of embryos transferred, without compromising the pregnancy rates.