The elaboration and biological activity of 15, containing the proposed pharmacophore for the antibiotic activity of the pyranonaphthoquinones, are reported. The synthetic strategy involved acid-catalyzed lactonization of mandelate 17 for isochroman ring formation, in combination with a Wittig-oxa-Michael functionalization of isochroman-3-ol derivative 20, a lactonization involving configurational inversion of a benzylic alcohol and a final AgO oxidation. Compound 15 showed activity against Staphylococcus aureus and Bacillus subtilis with MIC of 64 and 32 microg/mL, respectively.