Spanish online survey on informed consent for the performance of paracentesis. Do we have it? Do we use it?

Rev Esp Enferm Dig. 2020 Nov;112(11):854-859. doi: 10.17235/reed.2020.7179/2020.

Abstract

Introduction: informed consent is necessary for invasive procedures as a document that guarantees the ethical health relationship and patient safety.

Aims: to analyze whether we have and use informed consent documents for paracentesis in our hospitals and to obtain data on the technique.

Methods: a descriptive observational study was performed during December 2019, via a cross-sectional survey disseminated through social networks, aimed at specialists and residents of gastroenterology.

Results: two hundred and three anonymous surveys were included (55.2 % gastroenterologist and 44.8 % residents) from 74 hospitals in 34 Spanish provinces. Ninety respondents (44.3 %) stated that they had the document in their centers. Of these, 29 (32.2 %) always provided it, 31 (34.4 %) provided it sometimes and 21 (23.3 %) never. Seventy-two professionals (35.5 %) answered that they did not have it and 41 (20.5 %) selected "unknown". Of these, 77 (68.1 %) considered it was necessary to create this document, 31 (27.4 %) did not think it was necessary and five (4.4 %) did not answer. With regards to the technique, 173 (85.2 %) performed paracentesis under direct visualization and 30 (14.8 %) were eco-guided on most occasions. One hundred and nine (53.7 %) always applied local anesthetic, 80 (39.4 %) sometimes and 14 (6.9 %) did not. One hundred and sixty-seven respondents (82.3 %) considered it to be a simple technique versus 36 (17.7 %) who thought that it was of intermediate complexity. In terms of risk, 150 (73.5 %) considered it was low and 52 (25.6 %), medium. Ninety-nine (48.8 %) experienced minor complications and 37 (18.2 %) experienced major complications.

Conclusions: paracentesis is a common technique in digestive services and could be associated with complications, even though it is considered to be simple and safe. Due to the important intra- and inter-hospital variability that this technique presents, we consider standardized training in this technique is necessary, as well as the creation, spread and use of informed consents.

Publication types

  • Observational Study

MeSH terms

  • Cross-Sectional Studies
  • Humans
  • Informed Consent*
  • Paracentesis*
  • Surveys and Questionnaires