Acid-sensitive ion channels (ASICs) are sodium channels partially permeable to Ca2+ ions, listed among putative targets in central nervous system (CNS) diseases in which a pH modification occurs. We targeted novel compounds able to modulate ASIC1 and to reduce the progression of ischemic brain injury. We rationally designed and synthesized several diminazene-inspired diaryl mono- and bis-guanyl hydrazones. A correlation between their predicted docking affinities for the acidic pocket (AcP site) in chicken ASIC1 and their inhibition of homo- and heteromeric hASIC1 channels in HEK-293 cells was found. Their activity on murine ASIC1a currents and their selectivity vs mASIC2a were assessed in engineered CHO-K1 cells, highlighting a limited isoform selectivity. Neuroprotective effects were confirmed in vitro, on primary rat cortical neurons exposed to oxygen-glucose deprivation followed by reoxygenation, and in vivo, in ischemic mice. Early lead 3b, showing a good selectivity for hASIC1 in human neurons, was neuroprotective against focal ischemia induced in mice.