The influence of ball in/out of play and possession in elite soccer: Towards a more valid measure of physical intensity during competitive match-play

Eur J Sport Sci. 2023 Sep;23(9):1892-1902. doi: 10.1080/17461391.2023.2203120. Epub 2023 May 11.

Abstract

The physical demands of soccer match-play have typically been assessed using a low-resolution whole match approach ignoring whether the ball is in or out of play (BIP/BOP) and during these periods which team has possession. This study investigated the effect of fundamental match structure variables (BIP/BOP, in/out of possession) on the physical demands, and especially intensity, of elite match-play. For 1083 matches from a major European league, whole match duration, and player physical tracking data, were divided into BIP/BOP, and in/out of possession periods throughout the match, using on-ball event data. These distinct phases were used to derive absolute (m) and rate (m·min-1) of distance covered in total and within six speed categories during BIP/BOP and in/out possession. The rate of distance covered, an index of physical intensity, was >2-fold greater during BIP vs BOP. Whole match total distance covered was confounded by BIP time and poorly associated with physical intensity during BIP (r = 0.36). Whole match rates of distance covered substantially underestimated those during BIP, particularly for higher running speeds (∼-62%). Ball possession markedly effected physical intensity, with the rates of distance covered running (+31%), at high-speed (+30%) and in total (+7%) greater out than in possession. Whole match physical metrics underestimated the physical intensity during BIP, and thus the rate(s) of distance covered during BIP are recommended for accurate measurement of physical intensity in elite soccer. The greater demands of being out of possession support a possession-based tactical approach to minimise fatigue and its negative consequences.

Keywords: Ball-in-play; physical intensity; possession status.

Plain language summary

This large-scale study utilising >1000 elite level competitive matches found profound differences in rate of distance covered between periods of BIP vs BOP, being 2-fold higher overall and 8- to 33-fold higher for the rates of distance covered within running, high-speed and sprinting speed categories.Consequently, commonly used whole match physical metrics, that incorporate both BIP and BOP, such as distances covered but even rates of distance covered, were not valid indices of physical intensity (rate of distance covered) during BIP.Thus a more valid and direct approach to quantifying physical intensity during elite soccer match-play as the rate of distance covered during BIP is proposed.Utilising a unique within-match analysis the effect of possession (i.e. in vs out) revealed that teams covered ≥30% more running and high-speed distance while out than in possession during BIP.

MeSH terms

  • Athletic Performance*
  • Fatigue
  • Humans
  • Running*
  • Soccer*