Individual cells are the foundational unit of biology, and understanding their functions and interactions is critical to advancing our understanding of health and disease. Single cell proteomics has seen intense interest from mass spectrometrists, with a goal of quantifying the proteome of single cells by adapting current techniques used in bulk samples. To date, most method optimizations research has worked towards increasing the proteome coverage of single cells. One prominent technique multiplexes many individual cells into a single data acquisition event using isobaric labels. Accompanying the single cells, one label is typically used for a mixed set of many cells, called a carrier or boost channel. Although this improves peptide identification rates, several groups have examined the impact on quantitative accuracy as more cells are included in the carrier channel, e.g. 100x or 500x. This manuscript explores how impurities in the multiplexing reagent can lead to inaccurate quantification observed as a measurable signal in the wrong channel. We discover that the severe abundance differential between carrier and single cell, combined with the reagent impurities, can overshadow several channels typically used for single cells. For carrier amounts 100x and above, this contamination can be as abundant as true signal from a single cell. Therefore, we suggest limiting the carrier channel to a minimal amount and balance the goals of identification and quantification.