Anorectal manometry, radiology, and tests of simulated defecation were carried out in 14 severely constipated young women and 29 age-matched controls. The resting anal sphincter pressures were reduced in the patients, but the squeeze pressures, rectoanal inhibitory reflex, and rectal pressures upon balloon distention were all normal. At rest, the anorectal angle was more obtuse in the constipated group, but there was no overall increase in perineal descent in constipated patients compared with controls. The presence of a balloon in the rectum and the onset of pain were perceived in constipated patients at volumes that were not significantly different from those in normal volunteers. Constipated patients, however, required higher rectal volumes to induce the desire to defecate and to stimulate regular rectal contractions. Constipated patients also found it more difficult to pass simulated stools from the rectum than the normal controls and, unlike most normal controls, failed to inhibit their external anal sphincter on attempted defecation. These findings suggest that young women with severe constipation have great difficulty initiating the coordinated set of events that constitute a normal defecation response.