We examined and treated four patients with anophthalmic socket pain. Conditions responsible for this problem in this series included scleritis after evisceration, amputation neuroma, pain from a skull-base meningioma, and chemical dependency with drug-seeking behavior. The pain associated with the scleritis after evisceration responded to removal of the scleral remnant. The pain associated with the amputation neuroma responded to removal of the orbital implant and its pseudocapsule in which the amputation neuroma was embedded. The pain associated with the meningioma was intractable. The pain associated with the chemical dependency remained a persistent problem. A careful history and physical examination are critical in the evaluation of anophthalmic socket pain. Computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging may be helpful in some cases.